Thank you for the information For this case the issue is fixed in upcoming version.

I meant this:

1. Page id=1, comments are enabled.

2. The other page id=2, comments are disabled. I input there the following shortcode to display rating from page 1:

and I get this bug. These comments are from the other page so they should be shown.

@tomson, yes. In page settings, there is a setting "Enable comments". The bug happens, if comments are disabled.

This is not a bug.

Do you know that the rating shortcode is only based on the Rating Custom field in comment forms? So if you disable the comments, how do you expect the rating should be made? What is the mean to show rating if there is no way to rate for that rating? This is a logical issue not a bug. You should not use the shortcode if you've disabled the comments, because that rating is based on the rating field of comment form.

As far as i see you're trying to use the wpDiscuz rating shortcode on a page where wpDiscuz is not allowed. Am I right?

Please don't use the rating for non-singular (archive) pages. It's not finished yet. wpDiscuz 7 doesn't support it yet. We'll fix all CSS and add it in next Beta-9 version.

2. If I have only enabled rating without rating field in comments. I have empty space if comments are disabled.

on page with disabled comments, I get a bug that you can see on the screenshot. Once I turn on the comments, the bug disappeared.